Our Top Picks Guides Categories Gear & Peripherals Laptops PC Components Company How We Review About Us Contact
Our recommendations are made independently. As an Amazon Associate we may receive commissions from purchases. Learn more ›
Methodology

How We Review

Search any PC hardware category and you get thousands of listings, a dozen "best" lists that rank whatever pays most, and spec sheets that quote headline numbers no one can compare. Two laptops with the same processor name can differ widely in display quality, battery capacity, and cooling.

We do not run a lab and we do not pretend to. Our comparisons are built from manufacturer spec sheets and manuals, safety certifications, warranty terms, and verified owner feedback, then checked by a second editor before anything publishes. This page walks through that process end to end, in the order it actually happens.

6Stage process
2Editors on every guide
1Score formula for every product

Who Is Behind These Reviews

PC Gear Hunt is written and edited by a two-person team, not a content farm. Zack Novak, the founder, leads peripherals, displays, and laptops, and Brandon Castellano leads PC components and system building. One editor drafts each guide and the other checks it, which means there is nowhere to hide a shortcut.

Zack Novak
Zack Novak Founder & Senior Peripherals, Display, and Laptop Editor Full bio ›

Zack Novak is the founder of PC Gear Hunt and its Senior Peripherals, Display, and Laptop Editor. A competitive FPS player based in Raleigh, North Carolina, with a B.S. in Information Technology and Digital Media from North Carolina State University, he covers mechanical keyboards, lightweight gaming mice, high-refresh-rate monitors, laptops, and streaming audio gear. He turns sensor specs, switch actuation, and panel response times into practical advice for gamers.

Brandon Castellano
Brandon Castellano Lead PC Hardware Analyst Full bio ›

Brandon Castellano is the Lead PC Hardware Analyst at PC Gear Hunt. Based in Austin, Texas, and holding a B.S. in Computer Engineering from the University of Texas at Austin, he covers graphics cards, processors, motherboards, power supplies, and cooling. He reads VRM designs, power efficiency certifications, and community benchmark data to help PC builders put together balanced systems.

What We Judge Products On

Every product is assessed on the same five points in our written analysis. These are the questions worth asking about any product before it goes on your desk or into your PC, whatever the category. They shape the review, pros, cons, and who should skip a product; they are not inputs to the PGH Score, which is described further down.

01

Performance

Speed, responsiveness, display quality, capacity, or battery life, compared with other models in the same category and price band rather than with the brand's own marketing.

02

Build quality and durability

Materials, construction, cooling and thermal design, and recurring durability problems in verified owner feedback.

03

Ease of use and safety

Compatibility with common platforms and operating systems, ease of setup and daily use, and recognized certifications such as UL, FCC, 80 PLUS, or ENERGY STAR where they apply.

04

Value

What you get for the price, including cables, mounts, adapters, and accessories in the box, compared with the typical price range of the category.

05

Warranty and support

Warranty length and terms, availability of replacement parts and service, and how easy the manufacturer is to reach when something fails.

Sources We Rely On

Those five points only mean something if the facts behind them are real. This is where they come from.

Manufacturer spec sheets and manuals

The primary source for every number we publish, matched to the exact model number and captured from the current listing rather than an archived image.

Safety certifications and recalls

UL listings and FCC compliance where they apply, 80 PLUS efficiency ratings for power supplies, and the CPSC recall database, so open safety issues are flagged before a product is ranked.

Verified owner feedback

Patterns across verified-purchase reviews, read for recurring failures and support problems. The average star rating from verified Amazon buyers also feeds the PGH Score described below.

Live retail listings

Price, unit count, and bundle contents recorded at time of writing and re-checked on every update.

The Six-Stage Process

Turning those criteria and sources into a published guide happens in the same six steps every time. It is deliberately mechanical, so two runs through the same category land on a similar shortlist, because preference enters as late as possible.

Sweep the category

We list every product currently available in the category, not only the well-marketed ones, and record price, key specs, and what is in the box from the live listing.

Full sweep Live listings Price recorded

Verify the specs

Every spec is matched to the manufacturer's own spec sheet or manual by model number. Anything without a verifiable spec sheet is cut at this stage.

Model number matched Vague specs flagged

Normalize the numbers

Everything converts to comparable units: resolution, refresh rate, weight, battery capacity, storage capacity, and price. This is the step that stops marketing copy from making a weak product look strong.

Same units Per dollar

Check safety and recalls

Safety certifications are confirmed where published, and the CPSC recall database is checked. Where a rating is claimed but not evidenced, we record it as unverified.

UL 80 PLUS CPSC recalls

Score, label, and write

Each product gets its PGH Score from verified buyer ratings by the same formula. The written analysis, pros, cons, and who-should-skip-it notes are our editorial judgment from the research above.

PGH Score Editorial analysis

Second-editor review

Before anything goes live, the editor who did not draft the guide runs through it against a fixed checklist, not just a re-read.

Two editors Fixed checklist
What that final check covers

Step six is a check on the four things most likely to cause real harm or a bad purchase if we get them wrong, run again whenever the guide is updated, not just before the first publish.

Model numbers Does every spec match the exact model linked, not a similar variant or kit?
Power and capacity ratings Are wattage, battery capacity, and storage figures quoted exactly as the manufacturer states them?
Compatibility Do sockets, ports, and connection standards match what the guide says the product works with?
Recalls and cautions Open CPSC recalls and manufacturer cautions worth flagging.

How the PGH Score Works

The PGH Score is a simple, automatic conversion of a product's average rating from verified Amazon buyers into a 10-point score. It is calculated the same way for every product, and we do not adjust it by hand. Our own assessment lives in the written review, the pros and cons, and the notes on who should skip a product, not in the number. A high score tells you buyers are broadly satisfied; it does not tell you a product suits your specific setup.

PGH Score = 7.0 + (0.6 × average star rating), capped at 9.9. A 4.5-star average becomes 9.7, a 4.0-star average becomes 9.4, and a 3.5-star average becomes 9.1.

Reading the scale
9.7–9.9 Excellent

An average of about 4.5 stars or more from verified buyers.

9.3–9.6 Very good

An average of about 3.8 to 4.4 stars.

8.5–9.2 Good

An average of about 2.5 to 3.7 stars.

8.0–8.4 Fair

An average below about 2.5 stars.

Products that fall short of 8.0 do not make it into a published guide.

How We Decide Best Overall, Best Value and Best For

A ranked list is only useful if the labels mean something. Most roundups hand out "Best Value" to whatever is cheapest on the page. Ours are fixed rules applied to the PGH Score and current price, and only one product can hold each.

Best Overall Highest PGH Score in the guide If two products tie on score, the one with the lower current price takes the label.
Best Value Lowest current price among well-rated picks Only products with a PGH Score of 8.5 or higher qualify, so the label never goes to a cheap product buyers are unhappy with. If none qualifies, no Best Value is named.
Best for [use case] Strongest fit for one specific reader Awarded for a concrete need: a compact keyboard for a small desk, a lightweight mouse for large hands, a laptop for long days away from an outlet.
No label Most products get none A product can rank well and carry no label at all. We do not invent a superlative for every entry on the list.

Labels follow the rules above mechanically, so we cannot hand one to a product we happen to like. Where a labeled product has a real limitation, the written review says so.

Independence & How We Make Money

Affiliate disclosure

Every score and label above is worthless if it can be bought, so here is exactly how this site makes money. PC Gear Hunt is funded by affiliate commissions. When you buy through a link here we may earn a commission from the retailer, at no extra cost to you. That is the whole business model, and it comes with rules we hold ourselves to.

  • No brand pays for inclusion, a position, a PGH Score, or the removal of a criticism. There is no rate card because nothing is for sale.
  • We buy no sponsored reviews and accept no free product in exchange for coverage.
  • Commission rates are not part of the PGH Score or the label rules above.
  • No manufacturer sees a guide, a score, or a ranking before it publishes.

If a product we rate highly has no affiliate program, it stays in the guide, unlinked.

Where Our Method Stops

Stated limitations

A comparison built from research cannot replace months of daily use. These are the gaps, and we would rather name them than let a confident tone imply we filled them.

  • −We do not run a lab, so we cannot independently confirm performance, battery life, or durability figures beyond what manufacturers, certification bodies, and owner feedback report.
  • −A well-rated product can still be a poor fit for your hand size, your software, or the rest of your setup.
  • −Owner feedback is uneven. Some models have thousands of verified reviews and others very few, and we say so in the guide where it matters.
  • −Specs change without a name change, which is part of why every guide carries an update date rather than only a publish date.
  • −A PGH Score summarizes buyer satisfaction at one point in time. It is not a prediction of how a product performs in your specific setup.

Nothing on this site is professional or electrical advice, and our comparisons are not a substitute for the manufacturer's manual or your own judgment.

Power supplies, lithium batteries, and other electrical components can cause injury or property damage when misused. Read the product manual, unplug a PC from wall power before working inside it, never open a power supply unit, and stop using a battery that is swollen or damaged. A high PGH Score is a judgment about a product, never a recommendation for a specific build.

How We Keep Reviews Current

None of this stays fixed for long, so every guide carries a published date and a last-updated date, and substantial changes are noted at the top of the article rather than made quietly.

Specs & availability Each update Listed specs and availability re-checked against the live retail listing whenever a guide is updated.
Full re-review When models change Category re-swept and new products assessed when a model is replaced or discontinued, or a notable new release arrives.
Corrections On report Verified errors fixed in place and noted at the top of the guide.

Method FAQs

Do you use every product yourselves?+

No. Our reviews are research-based. We compare manufacturer spec sheets and manuals, safety certifications, warranty terms, and patterns in verified owner feedback. Where a figure comes from a third party, we cite whose figure it is rather than implying it was ours.

Can a brand pay to be included or ranked higher?+

No. We do not accept sponsored reviews, paid inclusion, or free product in exchange for coverage, and no brand sees a guide before publication. Affiliate commissions are paid by the retailer and do not vary by product.

Where does the PGH Score come from?+

It is calculated automatically from the average rating verified Amazon buyers give a product: 7.0 plus 0.6 per star, capped at 9.9. It is the same formula for every product, and we do not adjust it by hand. Because the scale starts at 7.0, published scores cluster between 8.0 and 9.9, and products under 8.0 are left out of published guides.

What exactly happens in that final check before a guide publishes?+

It is a fixed pass over four things: whether every spec matches the exact model number, whether power and capacity ratings are quoted exactly as stated, whether compatibility claims hold, and whether an open recall or caution is worth flagging. It runs again whenever the guide is updated, not only before the first publish.

Contents
  1. Who is behind these reviews
  2. What we judge products on
  3. Sources we rely on
  4. The six-stage process
  5. How the PGH Score works
  6. How we decide the labels
  7. Independence & funding
  8. Where our method stops
  9. Keeping reviews current